Finding Success in the Policy Cup Competition
Though a young organization, the Wharton Politics & Business Association has been building a healthy legacy on Penn’s campus. Much of this is due to the club’s annual Policy Cup Competition in which students across the University of Pennsylvania community, representing undergraduates and graduates across various fields of study, submit researched policy proposals to be judged by a panel of esteemed academics. The proposals fit within the club’s yearly focus. Of course, this academic year’s theme is “Globalization.” While the theme and applicable research questions change with every year, the process behind it is very consistent; the key to writing a successful policy paper is largely the same regardless of topic.
This October, WPBA Co-VP of Policy Development Doug Eckhardt gave an introduction for this year’s participants. What he presented was an overview of the questions for the current competition as well as tips on how to research and answer the competition prompts. Mr. Eckhardt himself is a former policy cup participant (he and his partner placed third in the competition last year). Perhaps the most pertinent advice given to 2009-2010 Policy Cup competitors regarded choosing a topic on which to write a proposal. Here is a brief summary of his recommendations:
- The topic should be “controversial,” meaning that it will spark debate and require the audience to question what you are presenting. Being forced to respond to difficult questions will require more meticulously researched proposals.
- The proposal should address an important issue rather than be more obscure. In other words, choose something you believe people will care about.
- Manage the scope of the topic your proposal discusses. If you have a general area of interest try to narrow it down to a specific problem under that umbrella. This will give your research greater focus.
- The topic should be of interest to you. Find an issue that will motivate you to remain committed to the competition and produce a well-polished proposal.
- The chosen topic should be “intellectually approachable” to you, meaning it will generate critical thought for you that will be mirrored in those reviewing your proposal.
- Lastly, be sure there are ample statistical references available to augment the roots of your arguments.
To those participating in the policy cup, I hope the following have helped you in some way. For prospective participants in future competitions feel free to keep these in mind as you mull over your decision. The PowerPoint presentation used by Mr. Eckhardt is available online.
Related posts:
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Subscribe to the Calendar